In Washington State, a new law about child abuse reporting has caused a big debate between church and state. Earlier this year, lawmakers passed a bill that added priests, pastors, and other religious leaders to the list of people who must report child abuse. This law was supposed to make sure every adult in a position of trust helped protect children from harm. But things got complicated when it came to the confessional.
What the Law Tried to Do
The law, known as Senate Bill 5375, said that clergy members had to report suspected child abuse or neglect if they learned about it. At first, this included anything said during confession or private talks between a person and their priest. The goal was to make sure no one could hide child abuse behind religious secrets.
But many church leaders spoke out against the law. Catholic bishops in Washington said that forcing priests to break the seal of confession went against their faith. In the Catholic Church, anything told in confession must stay private — no matter what. Breaking that rule could even get a priest excommunicated, which is one of the most serious punishments in the church.
Court Steps In
Soon after the law was passed, Catholic bishops and others filed a lawsuit. They argued that making priests report what they hear in confession violated the First Amendment, which protects freedom of religion. In July 2025, a federal judge agreed and blocked that part of the law from being enforced.
The judge said priests should not have to choose between following their faith or breaking the law. The court decided that forcing priests to reveal what was said in confession was likely unconstitutional.
Washington’s Final Decision
After the court ruling, the Washington Attorney General’s office made an agreement not to enforce that part of the law. This means that, for now, priests in Washington do not have to report child abuse if they only learn about it during confession.
However, if a priest or pastor learns about abuse in any other way — like through a normal conversation, email, or counseling — they are still legally required to report it to authorities. The rule only protects information heard solely in confession or similar sacred conversations in other faiths.
The Ongoing Debate
This issue has caused strong opinions on both sides. Child safety advocates believe all cases of abuse should be reported, no matter where the information comes from. They say that protecting children should come before protecting religious secrets.
On the other hand, religious groups say confession is a sacred act that must remain private. They believe that breaking the seal would destroy trust between clergy and their members. Many also fear it would open the door for the government to interfere with religion in other ways.
What Happens Next
For now, Washington State will not require priests to report child abuse confessed in church. But the debate isn’t over. Lawmakers may try to revise the law again, and the courts could take another look at the issue in the future.
Other states will also be watching closely. If Washington’s decision stands, it could set an example for how the rest of the country handles similar laws that balance faith and child protection.
Leave a Reply